What a Process Plant, a Prison, a Hospital and a Hotel Teach Modular Data Centre Designers
Data centres are not the only projects that can be delivered with a modular approach. Case studies exist across the built environment, and we examined four from outside our sector: a process plant, a prison, an emergency hospital and a hotel.
Each was built from repeatable off-site units under time pressure, with demanding requirements for security, safety or availability. Reviewed together, they answer a question data centre designers keep asking: when does modular actually pay off? Our first blog set out three working definitions of modular: modular components, containerised and modular data centres. This blog sets out the evidence behind our design approach.
Singapore Aromatics Plant: why do interfaces matter so much?
A US$800 million process plant on a space-constrained, partially reclaimed island site was delivered as 213 fully engineered modules with a combined weight of 26,870 tonnes. Each module was modelled in three-dimensional CAD and reviewed across engineering, operations and maintenance before fabrication. The modules were assembled, tested and pre-commissioned off-site, then barged in and installed at up to three a day. Design to handover took 32 months, and the project recorded one lost-time incident across more than 5 million work hours (Gibb, 1999).
The build was complicated, heavy on process, engineering and technology, and constrained by its site, which combines many of the factors we see on the data centre projects we deliver today. The lesson is that separating the systems into modules early in the design, and planning the installation, works only if the interfaces are defined and tested before fabrication. However, where they are not, the project exchanges one kind of site rework for another. The interfaces are therefore the critical issue, not the modules themselves.
Fazakerley Prison: where should compliance be verified?
Fazakerley was built from 216 precast concrete multicell modules, each cast in a 24-hour cycle using 50 N/mm² concrete, which is about 50 % above standard wall strength, to meet a 60-year design life under a 25-year concession. A 92-cell house block was erected in 12 days, roughly half the time of equivalent in-situ construction, with services and fixings integrated at manufacture (Gibb, 1999).
Each module was verified independently after fabrication against a fixed specification, and the security certification was attached to the module type. Once the first module had been fabricated, tested and completed, the rest could follow in turn. This is the repeatable-module approach we want for data centres, so that capacity can be added quickly and at scale. Factory Acceptance Testing verified at module level carries across all phases of data centre build-out, regardless of how many modules a facility ends up with. However, compliance verified once at final capacity is fragile to any later change, which makes module-level verification the more robust basis.
Vulcan Mountain Emergency Hospital: what does it teach about uncertainty?
The hospital was assembled from 1,800 standardised steel-frame modules (CIC MiC, n.d.) in a repeating fishbone layout. Infection control, including three-zone/two-channel segregation and negative-pressure gradients, was engineered into the module design instead of being verified ward by ward after construction (Chen et al., 2021). The interval from groundbreaking to operational capacity was about 10 days (Engineering News-Record, 2020).
It was built at speed for a use case of unknown duration. The plant and the prison were designed to last for decades while staying live. However, the hospital was designed for the length of the Covid outbreak, which nobody at the time could know. We see the same pattern in AI deployments today: IT development moves so fast that AI IT generations are measured in years, not decades. The response at Vulcan Mountain was to standardise the module and repeat it, instead of sizing a bespoke facility to a single forecast. Where the duration of demand is uncertain, a repeated standard module is generally the more robust response.
citizenM New York Bowery: where do you stop standardising?
The hotel was constructed from 210 steel-frame modules fabricated near Gdansk, Poland, and fitted out with furniture, wiring, control systems and sanitaryware before being shipped and craned into position (Levere, 2018). The lobby, café and rooftop bar, each unique in dimension and fit-out, were built conventionally (Construction Dive, 2018).
The lesson is to standardise where there is genuine repeatability and use traditional methods where there is not. In a data centre, the repeatable elements are EPODs, switch rooms, generators and the white space layout. The loading bay and offices can be modular. However, it is sometimes easier to build them conventionally on site as part of the shell and core. The boundary should be drawn by repeatability, not by a target percentage of off-site content.
What do the four have in common?
Three findings keep appearing. First, modularity delivers its full benefit only when it is built into the design from the outset, not applied later as a delivery method. Second, compliance is established at the module or type level and carried through by design. Third, the factory environment reduces risks that are harder to manage on a live or constrained construction site, such as quality control, testing and workforce safety.
The pressure varied from project to project; however, the certainty of the end product stayed constant, from very early design stages through to construction. Each of those findings maps onto one or more of Adaptive MDC's five design principles, which the next blogs in this series cover one at a time. Full references are in the white paper.
Modular Data Centre Design: A Philosophy, Not a Delivery Method
Sources
- CIC MiC (n.d.) Huoshenshan Hospital, Wuhan. Construction Industry Council, Hong Kong. Available at: mic.cic.hk/en/OverseasProjects/6.
- Chen, Y., Lei, J., Li, J., Zhang, Z., Yu, Z. and Du, C. (2021) Design Characteristics on the Indoor and Outdoor Air Environments of the COVID-19 Emergency Hospital. Journal of Building Engineering, 45, 103246. Available at: doi.org/10.1016/j.jobe.2021.103246.
- Construction Dive (2018) 21-Story Modular Hotel Opened in NYC Said to be Tallest in US. Construction Dive, 1 November 2018. Available at: constructiondive.com/news/21-story-modular-hotel-opened-in-nyc-said-to-be-tallest-in-us/541044/.
- Engineering News-Record (2020) Crews Complete Wuhan Hospital in 10 Days, Near Completion on Second Coronavirus Facility. ENR, 3 February 2020. Available at: enr.com/articles/48614.
- Gibb, A.G.F. (1999) Off-Site Fabrication: Prefabrication, Pre-Assembly and Modularisation. Whittles Publishing / John Wiley & Sons. Case Studies 4.2.4 (Singapore Aromatics Plant) and 4.3.4 (Fazakerley Prison, Merseyside).
- Levere, J. (2018) CitizenM Used Modular Construction for its Newest NYC Hotel. The Architect's Newspaper, 27 September 2018. Available at: archpaper.com/2018/09/citizenm-modular-nyc-hotel/.